• Sat, Oct 2025

Hidden Gems, and Local Favorites

Hidden Gems, and Local Favorites

Discover Martha's Vineyard like a local! Explore insider tips, hidden gems, and local favorites with our ultimate guide to the island's best-kept secrets.

Welcome to Your Ultimate Martha's Vineyard Guide!

This enchanting island off the coast of Massachusetts is a treasure trove of natural beauty, rich history, and vibrant culture. Whether you're planning your first visit or you're a seasoned traveler, this guide will help you uncover the true essence of Martha's Vineyard, from its pristine beaches to charming towns and everything in between.

Understanding Martha's Vineyard

Before diving into specifics, let's get acquainted with the island’s unique geography and character.

Geography and Towns

Martha's Vineyard is divided into six distinct towns, each with its own unique personality:

  • Edgartown: Known for its elegant historic district and picturesque harbor.
  • Oak Bluffs: Famous for its colorful gingerbread cottages and lively atmosphere.
  • Vineyard Haven (Tisbury): The year-round port and a hub of island activity.
  • West Tisbury: Home to beautiful farmland and the island’s agricultural heart.
  • Chilmark: Offering scenic vistas and some of the island's most exclusive real estate.
  • Aquinnah: Featuring dramatic clay cliffs and rich Native American heritage.

Island Culture

Martha’s Vineyard has a unique blend of New England charm, coastal living, and artistic flair. The island has long been a haven for creative types, politicians, and celebrities seeking a peaceful retreat. This mix has created a vibrant community that values both tradition and innovation.

Insider Tips for Visiting Martha's Vineyard

Timing Your Trip

Choose the best time to visit based on your preferences:

  • Peak Season (July-August): The island is bustling with activity, perfect for those who love a lively atmosphere.
  • Shoulder Season (May-June, September-October): Ideal for enjoying great weather with fewer crowds.
  • Off-Season (November-April): Experience the authentic island life, with lower prices and a more relaxed pace.

Pro Tip: Visit during late June or early September for the best balance of good weather and manageable crowds.

Getting There and Around

  • Ferries: The Steamship Authority operates year-round from Woods Hole, MA. In summer, additional services run from New Bedford, MA, Hyannis, MA, and Quonset Point, RI.
  • Air Travel: Martha's Vineyard Airport (MVY) offers connections to major East Coast cities.
  • Vineyard Transit Authority (VTA): Provides comprehensive bus service across the island.
  • Bike Rentals: Renting a bike is an excellent way to explore, with over 44 miles of bike paths.

Hidden Gems You Can't Miss

Beaches

  • Lobsterville Beach, Aquinnah: A quiet, two-mile stretch perfect for beachcombing and fishing. Visit early morning for spectacular sunrises.
  • Lambert's Cove Beach, West Tisbury: A secluded spot with calm waters, ideal for families. It’s resident-only during the day in summer but open to all for breathtaking sunsets.
  • Moshup Beach, Aquinnah: Known for its dramatic clay cliffs and clothing-optional section. Visit during low tide to explore tidal pools.

Nature Trails

  • Menemsha Hills Reservation: Offers 211 acres of woodland and coastal habitats, with a 3.5-mile loop trail providing stunning views of Vineyard Sound.
  • Felix Neck Wildlife Sanctuary: Features 4 miles of trails through diverse habitats. Join guided kayak tours for a unique perspective of the island’s ecology.
  • Wasque Reservation, Chappaquiddick: A remote paradise for nature lovers and fishermen. Watch for rare shorebirds and seals along the beach.

For more beach recommendations, explore our full Lambert's Cove Beach guide.

Cultural Sites

  • Aquinnah Cultural Center: Learn about the history and culture of the Wampanoag Tribe of Gay Head (Aquinnah). Guided tours of the historic clay cliffs are available.
  • Vincent House Museum, Edgartown: The oldest known house on the island, dating back to 1672. Offers a glimpse into early colonial life on Martha’s Vineyard.
  • Martha’s Vineyard Museum, Vineyard Haven: Housed in a beautifully restored marine hospital, featuring exhibits on island history, including its whaling past and coastal ecology.

Local Favorites for Food and Fun

Best Local Eateries

  • The Net Result, Vineyard Haven: A local institution famous for lobster rolls and fresh seafood. Try their homemade chowder or grab picnic supplies for a beach day.
  • State Road Restaurant, West Tisbury: Farm-to-table cuisine featuring locally sourced ingredients. Don’t miss their Sunday brunch, a favorite among locals.
  • Larsen’s Fish Market, Menemsha: A no-frills seafood shack offering the freshest catch. Grab dinner to go and enjoy it on the beach for a perfect Menemsha sunset.
  • Back Door Donuts, Oak Bluffs: Known for their “back door” service offering hot, fresh donuts at night. The apple fritters are a must-try island delicacy.

Off-the-Beaten-Path Activities

  • Kayak the Elizabeth Islands: Paddle around the quieter, scenic Elizabeth Islands for a unique perspective. Guided tours are available for those less experienced.
  • Island Alpaca Farm: Meet over 50 Huacaya alpacas and learn about sustainable farming. The farm store offers locally produced alpaca products.
  • Mytoi Japanese Garden, Chappaquiddick: A serene 14-acre garden with winding footpaths, small ponds, and native and exotic plants. Perfect for meditation or a peaceful picnic.
Your experience on this site will be improved by allowing cookies Cookie Policy