West Tisbury: Farms, Forests, and Quiet Island Life

West Tisbury is the rural heart of Martha’s Vineyard — a town defined by forests, farmland, conservation trails, and one of the island’s most beloved beaches. It’s quieter than the down-island towns, but culturally rich, nature-focused, and historically significant. Originally settled in 1669 and incorporated in 1892, West Tisbury is where the island’s agricultural traditions remain strongest.

Historical Background

West Tisbury’s early history centers on farming, mills, and close-knit settlement patterns. For more than three centuries, agriculture shaped the landscape — from sheep farms and cranberry bogs to today’s conservation land. The town still carries the atmosphere of an older Vineyard, with winding roads, stone walls, and historic properties preserved across its hills and forests.

What Makes West Tisbury Special

Agricultural Heritage

The town’s identity is anchored in farming. The West Tisbury Farmers Market — held at the Agricultural Hall — is the island’s largest and oldest market, running Wednesdays and Saturdays from June through October. Local vegetables, flowers, honey, baked goods, and prepared foods reflect the island’s artisan culture.

Lambert’s Cove Beach

Lambert’s Cove Beach is West Tisbury’s crown jewel — soft white sand, warm water, and one of the prettiest sunset spots on the Vineyard. Access requires a resident pass in peak season, but many rentals include one.

Hiking & Nature

West Tisbury has some of the island’s best trail systems, managed by the Sheriff’s Meadow Foundation, the MV Land Bank, and the Trustees of Reservations. Popular areas include:

• Cedar Tree Neck Sanctuary — dramatic cliffs, forest, and shoreline.
• Sepiessa Point Preserve — ponds, meadows, and quiet coastal views.
• Priester’s Pond & Duarte’s Pond — peaceful walking areas.

Polly Hill Arboretum

A botanical landmark with rare plants, winding paths, and year-round public access. Summer tours and seasonal events attract gardeners and visitors from around the world.

Arts & Culture

Alley’s General Store

Founded in 1859, Alley’s General Store is the oldest retail business on the island — a West Tisbury icon. Owned by the Vineyard Preservation Trust, it functions as a general store, community hub, and gathering point for locals.

Art & Craft Scene

West Tisbury is home to several of the island’s most beloved art venues:

• Vineyard Artisans Festival — held at the historic Grange Hall.
• Granary Gallery — classic Vineyard photography and fine art.
• Field Gallery — famous for its whimsical outdoor sculptures.
• Glassworks Studio — real-time glassblowing demonstrations.

Annual Agricultural Fair

The MV Agricultural Fair is one of the island’s biggest events — a four-day celebration of farming, rides, competitions, food, and community. It’s a cornerstone of West Tisbury’s identity and draws thousands every August.

Lodging & Transportation

Lambert’s Cove Inn is the town’s signature lodging option — quiet, refined, and close to nature. The rest of West Tisbury is primarily home rentals, making it ideal for longer stays and families.

Having a car is recommended, but the VTA bus system connects the town well. Many rural roads lack bike paths — ride with caution.

Why Visit West Tisbury

If you’re looking for a peaceful part of Martha’s Vineyard with strong local culture, pristine trails, quiet beaches, and a community built around farming and creativity — West Tisbury is the place.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What’s the best time to visit?
A: Summer offers the most events, but spring and fall are gorgeous for hiking.

Q: What landmarks should I see?
A: Polly Hill Arboretum, Lambert’s Cove Beach, Alley’s General Store.

Q: What can I do here?
A: Hiking, beach days, farmers markets, art festivals, and nature exploration.

Fun Facts

• West Tisbury was the last Vineyard town to be incorporated (1892).
• Home to the island’s largest farmers market.
• Alley’s General Store is the oldest shop on Martha’s Vineyard.
• Lambert’s Cove is consistently ranked among the island’s best beaches.